Today, we go into the Night Buddies archives to find Crosley’s favorite snack recipe. In May 2014, we originally published the recipe for Crusted Creme Fro-Madge.  Here it is again. It’s the perfect treat to celebrate the end of school and the beginning of summer. Enjoy!

Share pictures of your Fro-Madge with us on social media!

From the Night Buddies archives, May 20, 2014.

In Night Buddies, Impostors, and One Far-Out Flying Machine, Crosley introduces John to his favorite flavor of frozen yogurt, the Crusted Crème Fro-Madge. Cros can slurp his Fro-Madges in one gulp, and when he doesn’t eat them, they’re great for attacking the Iguana Gang!

Whether you need a yummy late-night snack or you need to fend off some Iguanas, we’re giving you the secret recipe for a Crusted Crème Fro-Madge frozen yogurt of your very own. You’ll be able to make Crosley’s favorite snack right in your own home!

First, what you’ll need is:

2-4 cups of whipped cream

1 pint of vanilla frozen yogurt

2 Tablespoons sugar

12 teaspoons ground cinnamon


Line a square cake pan with parchment paper. Using a 1 3/4-inch ice cream scoop, make four balls of frozen yogurt and place them on the parchment. Once that is done, transfer your pan to the freezer and let the yogurt harden for at least half an hour.

Once the yogurt has hardened, take out the frozen yogurt balls and cover them in whipped cream, topping them off with a sprinkle of sugar and cinnamon. Freeze again for fifteen minutes.

Now you’re almost done! Place each dessert ball on a dish and drizzle them with honey. These are best when served immediately, so make sure you gobble them up as quickly as Crosley would!